Let’s be honest—watching your dog go bonkers over a new toy is one of the best parts of being a dog parent. But not all toys are made equal, and finding the right kind of toy for your dog can make a massive difference. The right toy doesn’t just stop them from chewing your shoes (although, yes please), it helps keep them happy, active, and out of mischief.
We’ve tried and tested a lot of toys here at Postman Pooch—on our own dogs, on customer dogs, and on some very enthusiastic testers—and here’s what we’ve learned.
Why Playtime Toys Actually Matter
It’s not just about burning off energy. Toys can:
- Keep your dog mentally stimulated (especially important for smart or easily bored dogs)
- Help with anxiety and restlessness
- Strengthen your bond (especially through tug-of-war or puzzle games)
- Give them something to do while you get five minutes’ peace
Types of Dog Toys (And What They’re Good For)
There are loads of options out there, so here’s a quick breakdown of what we’ve found works best—depending on your dog’s vibe.
🧸 Plush Dog Toys
Best for: Cuddly dogs or gentle players
These are your soft, squeaky, often hilarious-looking toys (like our birthday cakes or prosecco bottles). Some dogs just love carrying them around or using them as pillows.
🦴 Rubber & Latex Toys
Best for: Chewers and teething pups
These toys are built to last and give dogs something satisfying to gnaw on. Think KONGs (we love these), squeaky bones, or anything that bounces weirdly to keep them guessing.
🧠 Puzzle & Interactive Toys
Best for: Brainy dogs or food-motivated pups
Toys you can stuff with treats or hide snacks in. Great for dogs who get bored easily or need a bit of a challenge.
🪢 Rope Toys
Best for: Tug-of-war champs
They’re sturdy, fun to throw, and good for cleaning teeth too. Most dogs love a game of tug with their favourite human (or dog sibling).
🔊 Squeaky Toys
Best for: Dogs who love instant feedback
Some dogs live for the squeak—it’s like a win every time they bite down. Our “Silly Squeakers” are always a hit.
Picking Toys That Suit Your Dog
Dogs are like people—they’ve all got their own preferences. Here's a rough guide based on age and personality:
Puppies
They’re teething, exploring, and often a bit chaotic. Go for softer rubber toys, teething rings, or small plushies they can carry.
Adults
These dogs usually need a mix of toys—some for play, some for chewing, and some to keep them mentally busy. Rotate toys to keep things fresh!
Seniors
Older dogs tend to slow down a bit. Soft toys or easy-to-nibble chews are great. Puzzle feeders can also help keep their minds active without too much effort.
Match Toys to Personality
- The Energetic One – Try rope toys, squeaky balls, or anything they can chase
- The Gentle Soul – Plush toys or comfort toys they can snuggle with
- The Hardcore Chewer – Durable rubber toys or latex bones (KONG Extreme is ideal)
- The Food Obsessed – Puzzle toys, treat balls, or anything you can fill with snacks
Why We’re Fussy About Toy Quality
Cheap toys might save you money upfront, but if they fall apart in 10 minutes—or worse, become a choking hazard—it’s not worth it. We only stock toys we trust, and that we’d give our own dogs. Safety, durability, and fun: that’s the rule.
Some Top Picks from Us:
- Plush Toys – Great for photos and play
- Natural Treat Bundles – Combine play with tasty rewards
- Monthly Dog Subscription Boxes – A new surprise every month, tailored to your dog’s needs
And yep—free delivery over £40, same-day dispatch if you order before 2pm, and you’ll earn Pooch Points too.
Final Word
Toys aren’t just about fun (though that’s a big part of it)—they help your dog stay healthy, happy, and a little less likely to destroy your sofa cushions. Whether your dog’s the cuddly type, a big-time chewer, or always on the hunt for snacks, the right toy makes all the difference.
Have a browse through our toy range and let your dog try something new—you might be surprised what they go mad for.
